Find the Horsetooth Hot Sauce product you’re looking for! Buy hot sauce, BBQ Sauce, and Bloody Mary Mix from Horsetooth Hot Sauce for yourself, or for a friend, and keep your eye out for new small batch hot sauces.
Horsetooth Hot Sauce Gift Boxes
A Horsetooth Hot Sauce Gift Box is the perfect birthday gift for that hard-to-shop-for person in your life. Mix and match 3 different hot sauces to get the perfect variety! Want more than hot sauce? Email us at horsetoothhotsauce@gmail.com to ask about gift baskets that can include any of our products, including hot sauce, BBQ sauce, Bloody Mary mix, t-shirts, and Horsetooth Hot Sauce shwag!
Horsetooth Hot Sauce, Hot & Bottled in Fort Collins, Colorado
The “O” Face ($5)
O… O… O, man is that hot! The “O” Face doesn’t mess around. It’s our spiciest sauce. We take premium orange habanero peppers – famous for their intense heat – and blend them with juicy cantaloupe and sweet carrots to tame the flame just a little bit. Use sparingly and be prepared to show us your “O” Face.
Horsetooth Hot Sauce, Hot & Bottled in Fort Collins, Colorado
Naughty #4 ($5)
One seriously sassy sauce, Naughty #4 is made with the kind of pepper you wouldn’t bring home to mother. Spicier than most, the intimidating scotch bonnet is coveted worldwide for her distinctively hot flavor. A little tango with the mango brings out the best in this naughty pepper. Proceed with caution.
Horsetooth Hot Sauce, Hot & Bottled in Fort Collins, Colorado
Rubin’s Red ($5)
Rubin’s Red packs a spicy bite, but won’t devour you whole. Named after our fierce & feisty (but relatively harmless) blue heeler, this flavorful sauce will sneak up and nip ya in the taste buds. Prized cayenne peppers are partnered with fresh black peppercorns and garlic to create the milder bark in this hot dog of a sauce.
Horsetooth Hot Sauce, Hot & Bottled in Fort Collins, Colorado
The Green ($5)
Don’t let its calm color fool you – The Green is mean. Feisty green habaneros and sizzling serranos pair with juicy tomatillos, garlic and onion in this heady sauce that will have even your tongue sweating bullets. Miles from mild, The Green is a spicy concoction of garden-fresh flavor and unrelenting heat.
Horsetooth Hot Sauce, Hot & Bottled in Fort Collins, Colorado
Rubin’s XXX ($5)
Not for the faint of heart, Rubin’s XXX is a spicier, steamier, sizzlier version of Rubin’s Red, our irresistible black pepper and garlic cayenne sauce. Rubin gets all fired up in this NC-17 version,tossing intense red habaneros into the mix for tongue-blasting heat that should come with a parental warning. Rubin’s XXX – because one X just wasn’t enough.
Horsetooth Hot Sauce, Hot & Bottled in Fort Collins, Colorado
Smokestack Lightning ($5)
Whoo hoo! It’s a smoky sauce. Smokestack Lighting pairs smoky Chipotle peppers with fresh garlic perfectly to make any aficionado howl with delight. This sauce smolders with a complexity of flavors that can ignite any taste bud. Fire up any dish with this classic smoky favorite.
Horsetooth Hot Sauce, Hot & Bottled in Fort Collins, Colorado
The Dog That Bit You (Bloody Mary Mix) ($8)
You woke up licking your wounds from a night of excess imbibement. Perhaps you need a little hair of the dog that bit you? That’s where our The Dog That Bit You Bloody Mary Mix comes in, with just enough Rubin’s XXX to make you forget the pain from the night before.
Horsetooth Hot Sauce, Hot & Bottled in Fort Collins, Colorado
The Wake up Call (Spicy Bloody Mary Mix) ($8)
Having trouble getting out of your head? You need a little wake-up call with Horsetooth Hot Sauce Bloody Mary mix. The Wake-up Call balances spices and Rubin’s Red to give you a flavor that will get you going so you can face a day that could have been less than stellar. Let our Wake-up call get you up on the right side of bed.
Horsetooth Hot Sauce, Hot & Bottled in Fort Collins, Colorado
Aloha Mr. Hand (Pineapple, Habanero) BBQ Sauce ($6)
Barbecuing is not a sport. It’s a way of life, you know, a hobby. It’s a way at looking at that
meat and saying. “Hey bud, lets party!” Aloha Mr. Hand combines the tasty heat of habaneros with the cool buzz of pineapple to make your mouth
feel fine.
Horsetooth Hot Sauce, Hot & Bottled in Fort Collins, Colorado
Hot Mess (Cutthroat Porter ®, Bourbon, Coffee) BBQ Sauce ($6)
A mess of ribs. A mess of wings or a mess of brisket. It don’t matter. Turn them into a hot mess with our slatherin’ sauce. Hot Mess Slatherin’ sauce combines the tradition of dark brown sugar and sweet molasses with Odell’s Cutthroat Porter ® and dark coffee. Together, these ingredients complement each other to create a rich, sweet sauce, perfect for any type of meat. (We recommend ribs and brisket). Make yourself a Hot Mess of your favorite meat and enjoy!
